Text Swell Reader

Languages:

400px

2.0s

Aspasia: Hi Socrates. This evening, at Cephalus’ symposium, we shall discuss the nature of democracy.

2.0s

Greek audio via server

Ασπασία:

2.0s

Aspasia:

2.0s

אספסיה:

2.0s

Aspasia:

2.0s

Socrates: Hi Aspasia. That discussion is long overdue, because what people call democracy is really an oligarchy.

2.0s

Greek audio via server

Σωκράτης:

2.0s

Sokrates:

2.0s

סוקרטס:

2.0s

Sokrates:

2.0s

Aspasia: That is true. In democracy power is never delegated but exerciced by the citizens themselves.

2.0s

Greek audio via server

Ασπασία:

2.0s

Aspasia:

2.0s

אספסיה:

2.0s

Aspasia:

2.0s

Socrates: Right. In a democracy, power is not delegated; it is exercised directly by the citizens.

2.0s

Greek audio via server

Σωκράτης:

2.0s

Sokrates:

2.0s

סוקרטס:

2.0s

Sokrates:

2.0s

Aspasia: Exactly. Power is exercised on a personal and rotational basis, with each adult citizen taking turns in alphabetical order.

2.0s

Greek audio via server

Ασπασία:

2.0s

Aspasia:

2.0s

אספסיה:

2.0s

Aspasia:

2.0s

Socrates: At times, a word’s etymology coincides perfectly with its definition. Democracy is such a case.

2.0s

Greek audio via server

Σωκράτης:

2.0s

Sokrates:

2.0s

סוקרטס:

2.0s

Sokrates:

2.0s

Aspasia: The verbs ΚΡΑΤΩ or ΚΡΑΤΕΩ mean “to exercise power” or “to be in effective control.”

2.0s

Greek audio via server

Ασπασία:

2.0s

Aspasia:

2.0s

אספסיה:

2.0s

Aspasia:

2.0s

Socrates: While ΚΡΑΤΙΑ (-cracy) is a morphologically valid word, it appears exclusively as the second element in compounds.

2.0s

Greek audio via server

Σωκράτης:

2.0s

Sokrates:

2.0s

סוקרטס:

2.0s

Sokrates:

2.0s

Aspasia: There are plenty of them: democracy, aristocracy, plutocracy, theocracy, kleptocracy, bureaucracy, kakistocracy, among others.

2.0s

Greek audio via server

Ασπασία:

2.0s

Aspasia:

2.0s

אספסיה:

2.0s

Aspasia:

2.0s

Socrates: In all the words you mentioned, the first element denotes the agent—whether personal or institutional—and the second denotes the exercise of power by that agent.

2.0s

Greek audio via server

Σωκράτης:

2.0s

Sokrates:

2.0s

סוקרטס:

2.0s

Sokrates:

2.0s

Aspasia: Yes. And ΔΗΜΟΣ (dēmos) means “the people,” in the sense of the citizenry.

2.0s

Greek audio via server

Ασπασία:

2.0s

Aspasia:

2.0s

אספסיה:

2.0s

Aspasia:

2.0s

Aspasia: Hi Socrates. This evening, at Cephalus’ symposium, we shall discuss the nature of democracy.

2.0s

Greek audio via server

Ασπασία:

2.0s

Aspasia:

2.0s

אספסיה:

2.0s

Aspasia:

2.0s

Socrates: Hi Aspasia. That discussion is long overdue, because what people call democracy is really an oligarchy.

2.0s

Greek audio via server

Σωκράτης:

2.0s

Sokrates:

2.0s

סוקרטס:

2.0s

Sokrates:

2.0s

Aspasia: That is true. In democracy power is never delegated but exerciced by the citizens themselves.

2.0s

Greek audio via server

Ασπασία:

2.0s

Aspasia:

2.0s

אספסיה:

2.0s

Aspasia:

2.0s

Socrates: Right. In a democracy, power is not delegated; it is exercised directly by the citizens.

2.0s

Greek audio via server

Σωκράτης:

2.0s

Sokrates:

2.0s

סוקרטס:

2.0s

Sokrates:

2.0s

Aspasia: Exactly. Power is exercised on a personal and rotational basis, with each adult citizen taking turns in alphabetical order.

2.0s

Greek audio via server

Ασπασία:

2.0s

Aspasia:

2.0s

אספסיה:

2.0s

Aspasia:

2.0s

Socrates: At times, a word’s etymology coincides perfectly with its definition. Democracy is such a case.

2.0s

Greek audio via server

Σωκράτης:

2.0s

Sokrates:

2.0s

סוקרטס:

2.0s

Sokrates:

2.0s

Aspasia: The verbs ΚΡΑΤΩ or ΚΡΑΤΕΩ mean “to exercise power” or “to be in effective control.”

2.0s

Greek audio via server

Ασπασία:

2.0s

Aspasia:

2.0s

אספסיה:

2.0s

Aspasia:

2.0s

Socrates: While ΚΡΑΤΙΑ (-cracy) is a morphologically valid word, it appears exclusively as the second element in compounds.

2.0s

Greek audio via server

Σωκράτης:

2.0s

Sokrates:

2.0s

סוקרטס:

2.0s

Sokrates:

2.0s

Aspasia: There are plenty of them: democracy, aristocracy, plutocracy, theocracy, kleptocracy, bureaucracy, kakistocracy, among others.

2.0s

Greek audio via server

Ασπασία:

2.0s

Aspasia:

2.0s

אספסיה:

2.0s

Aspasia:

2.0s

Socrates: In all the words you mentioned, the first element denotes the agent—whether personal or institutional—and the second denotes the exercise of power by that agent.

2.0s

Greek audio via server

Σωκράτης:

2.0s

Sokrates:

2.0s

סוקרטס:

2.0s

Sokrates:

2.0s

Aspasia: Yes. And ΔΗΜΟΣ (dēmos) means “the people,” in the sense of the citizenry.

2.0s

Greek audio via server

Ασπασία:

2.0s

Aspasia:

2.0s

אספסיה:

2.0s

Aspasia:

2.0s

Socrates: So, democracy is a system in which each citizen exercises political power.

2.0s

Greek audio via server

Σωκράτης:

2.0s

Sokrates:

2.0s

סוקרטס:

2.0s

Sokrates:

2.0s

Aspasia: Yes, each such exercise should last for as short a time as possible, depending on the demographics of the political entity in question.

2.0s

Greek audio via server

Ασπασία:

2.0s

Aspasia:

2.0s

אספסיה:

2.0s

Aspasia:

2.0s

Socrates: Let us posit 10 days per year serving as a legislator on the city council, 10 days per year serving as a police officer, and 10 days per year serving as a judge or juror.

2.0s

Greek audio via server

Σωκράτης:

2.0s

Sokrates:

2.0s

סוקרטס:

2.0s

Sokrates:

2.0s

Aspasia: Yes, it is clear that democracy and extended periods of power are mutually exclusive.

2.0s

Greek audio via server

Ασπασία:

2.0s

Aspasia:

2.0s

אספסיה:

2.0s

Aspasia:

2.0s

Socrates: And, contrary to popular belief, voting is not evidence of democracy but evidence that the political system in place is undemocratic.

2.0s

Greek audio via server

Σωκράτης:

2.0s

Sokrates:

2.0s

סוקרטס:

2.0s

Sokrates:

2.0s

Aspasia: Yes, democracy renders voting redundant.

2.0s

Greek audio via server

Ασπασία:

2.0s

Aspasia:

2.0s

אספסיה:

2.0s

Aspasia:

2.0s

Socrates: Also, democracy is the ultimate decentralization of power. It cannot get more decentralized than that.

2.0s

Greek audio via server

Σωκράτης:

2.0s

Sokrates:

2.0s

סוקרטס:

2.0s

Sokrates:

2.0s

Aspasia: In effect, then, democracy has never been implemented anywhere so far.

2.0s

Greek audio via server

Ασπασία:

2.0s

Aspasia:

2.0s

אספסיה:

2.0s

Aspasia:

2.0s

Socrates: That is correct, Aspasia.

2.0s

Greek audio via server

Σωκράτης:

2.0s

Sokrates:

2.0s

סוקרטס:

2.0s

Sokrates:

2.0s

Aspasia: So, why do they call oligarchy democracy?

2.0s

Greek audio via server

Ασπασία:

2.0s

Aspasia:

2.0s

אספסיה:

2.0s

Aspasia:

2.0s

Socrates: We all know the answer to that: to mislead the public into believing that citizens are in control, when in fact they are not.

2.0s

Greek audio via server

Σωκράτης:

2.0s

Sokrates:

2.0s

סוקרטס:

2.0s

Sokrates:

2.0s

Aspasia: That is a condescending attitude on the part of the oligarchs, is it not?

2.0s

Greek audio via server

Ασπασία:

2.0s

Aspasia:

2.0s

אספסיה:

2.0s

Aspasia:

2.0s

Socrates: It is condescending and dismissive, which is what citizens deserve if they delegate power to others.

2.0s

Greek audio via server

Σωκράτης:

2.0s

Sokrates:

2.0s

סוקרטס:

2.0s

Sokrates:

2.0s

Aspasia: To what extent does democracy guarantee the elimination of corruption?

2.0s

Greek audio via server

Ασπασία:

2.0s

Aspasia:

2.0s

אספסיה:

2.0s

Aspasia:

2.0s

Socrates: To a great extent because corruption thrives where power is continuous and concentrated. Short, rotating mandates drastically reduce incentives and opportunities for corrupt networks.

2.0s

Greek audio via server

Σωκράτης:

2.0s

Sokrates:

2.0s

סוקרטס:

2.0s

Sokrates:

2.0s

Aspasia: No permanent political class. Corruption depends on specialization in power. When citizens exercise power temporarily and return to private life, corruption loses continuity.

2.0s

Greek audio via server

Ασπασία:

2.0s

Aspasia:

2.0s

אספסיה:

2.0s

Aspasia:

2.0s

Socrates: Also, it promotes immediate accountability. When today’s decision-maker is tomorrow’s ordinary citizen, corrupt behavior becomes self-deterring.

2.0s

Greek audio via server

Σωκράτης:

2.0s

Sokrates:

2.0s

סוקרטס:

2.0s

Sokrates:

2.0s

Aspasia: Moreover, proximity forges transparency. Corruption flourishes in distance—bureaucratic, temporal, and social. Direct civic governance collapses that distance.

2.0s

Greek audio via server

Ασπασία:

2.0s

Aspasia:

2.0s

אספסיה:

2.0s

Aspasia:

2.0s

Socrates: But democracy probably cannot eliminate corruption altogether. Even under ideal democratic conditions, humans remain capable of self-interest and collusion.

2.0s

Greek audio via server

Σωκράτης:

2.0s

Sokrates:

2.0s

סוקרטס:

2.0s

Sokrates:

2.0s

Aspasia: Not in the short run, but it might if practiced for a long time.

2.0s

Greek audio via server

Ασπασία:

2.0s

Aspasia:

2.0s

אספסיה:

2.0s

Aspasia:

2.0s

Socrates: Yes, in that case citizens might finally see that corruption is detrimental to everyone's quality of life.

2.0s

Greek audio via server

Σωκράτης:

2.0s

Sokrates:

2.0s

סוקרטס:

2.0s

Sokrates:

2.0s

Socrates: Therefore, corruption can be minimized structurally but never metaphysically abolished.

2.0s

Greek audio via server

Σωκράτης:

2.0s

Sokrates:

2.0s

סוקרטס:

2.0s

Sokrates:

2.0s

Socrates: Right. Small-scale corruption can still occur episodically. Informal influence and social pressure cannot be fully eradicated.

2.0s

Greek audio via server

Σωκράτης:

2.0s

Sokrates:

2.0s

סוקרטס:

2.0s

Sokrates: